If you are a landlord or tenant considering a rental, you have probably wondered which is the best option: a short-term rental or a long-term rental. Although both models may seem similar, there are key differences in regulations, length of stay, taxation, and rights that you need to be aware of in order to make the most informed decision.
In this article, we explain in detail the differences between short-term holiday rentals and long-term seasonal rentals, as well as their implications for landlords and tenants.
What is a short-term holiday rental?
A short-term holiday rental, also known as a holiday let, involves renting out a fully equipped property to travellers for short periods of time, usually by the day or week.
Key features of short-term rentals
- Duration: Properties are rented out for short stays, usually less than 31 days.
- Regulations: Each autonomous community sets specific regulations, and in most cases a tourist licence is required.
- Listing platforms: It is advertised on specialised platforms such as Airbnb, Booking, Vrbo, or Expedia.
- Additional services: These may include cleaning, changing of bed linen, customer service, and other services similar to those offered by a hotel.
- Taxation: It is subject to a specific tax regime and, in some cases, to VAT if hotel services are provided.
What is seasonal rental?
Seasonal rental is a tenancy agreement for a fixed period of more than 31 days, aimed at people who need temporary accommodation for work, academic, or personal reasons.
Key features of seasonal rental
- Duration: This usually ranges from one to eleven months, without constituting a primary residence.
- Regulations: It is governed by the Urban Leases Act (LAU), but is not considered a primary residence.
- Listing platforms: It is advertised on property portals such as Idealista, Fotocasa, or Habitaclia.
- Additional services: It is not mandatory to include additional services such as cleaning or maintenance.
- Taxation: It is declared as income from property investment on personal income tax returns, with no VAT applicable.
Key differences between holiday rentals and seasonal rentals
Below, we compare the two types of rentals based on the most relevant aspects:
1. Contract duration
- Holiday rental: Short-term, generally less than 31 days.
- Seasonal rental: Medium to long term, from 1 to 11 months.
2. Legal regulations and licences
- Tourist rental: Requires specific licences depending on the autonomous community and is subject to strict regulations.
- Seasonal rental: Governed by the Urban Leasehold Act (LAU) and does not require tourist licences.
3. Taxation and tax obligations
- Holiday rental: May be subject to VAT if additional services are provided.
- Seasonal rental: Declared in personal income tax as income from property investment.
4. Key differences for landlords and tenants
For landlords
- Holiday rental: May require licences and greater administrative effort. Must comply with specific local regulations and may be subject to inspections.
- Seasonal rental: Fewer regulations and administrative tasks, but longer contracts that limit the landlord’s flexibility.
For tenants
- Tourist rental: Ideal for short stays, but the price per night is usually higher than a seasonal rental. Does not offer the stability of a mid-term contract.
- Seasonal rental: Greater stability and generally lower monthly rent, but without the convenience and flexibility of a holiday rental.
Advantages and disadvantages of short-term rentals
Advantages
- Flexibility in the use of the property.
- Available on wide-reaching platforms.
- Allows for more dynamic property management.
Disadvantages
- Strict regulations and the need for licences.
- Higher tenant turnover and more complex management.
- Potential dependency on tourist seasons.
Advantages and disadvantages of Seasonal Rentals
Advantages
- Greater stability in occupancy.
- Fewer regulations and legal requirements.
- A more stable relationship between landlord and tenant.
Disadvantages
- Cannot be rented as a primary residence.
- Less flexibility for the owner if they wish to use the property themselves.
Which is the best option for you?
The choice between tourist rental and seasonal rental will depend on the needs and circumstances of owners and tenants:
- If you are looking for accommodation for a short period, a tourist rental is the best option.
- If you need a more stable temporary rental, without it being a permanent residence, a seasonal rental is more suitable.
Before deciding, check local regulations and see which option best suits your situation.
Stay informed about the latest trends and opportunities in the property market by subscribing to our newsletter!
